• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Rusty's Pizza Parlor

Rusty's Pizza Parlor, nestled in the heart of Santa Barbara at 232 W Carrillo St, is a beloved local institution renowned for its exceptional pizza and charming medieval decor. Customers laud its variety, from savory chicken barbecue to flavorful salads, ensuring there's something for everyone. Despite mixed reviews on service, many agree that the pizza is stellar, with some claiming it to be the best they've had in years. The unique motifs at each location add to the experience, making Rusty's not just a place to grab a bite, but a delightful stop for pizza enthusiasts seeking quality and character.

Rusty's Pizza Parlor: Reviews & Ratings

Brian Wangenheim
Brian Wangenheim

Pizza was pretty good, but the service was kind of lacking, didn’t really feel welcomed and lots of people just randomly walking around not helping out with drinks or anything. Kind of distracting but overall it’s an all right place for pizza.

Pasqual Gonzalez
Pasqual Gonzalez

Best pizza I've had in a long time ...

Marlene Da Silva
Marlene Da Silva

We got the chicken barbecue pizza (look at my pictures) that was a great pizza and not too greasy. The inside and outside are medieval style, very cute. The staff is nice, I recommend.

Guthrie Paterson
Guthrie Paterson

A Santa Barbara institution and must pick-up/delivery spot (in-house dinning a “unique” experience). Very helpful staff, quick prep and excellent pizza. Prepared salads are great too!

Darrell Kellam
Darrell Kellam

Recently moved from LA. Salad bar is great, pizza is some of the best that I have ever had. Cool motifs. Each location has a different motif. Highly recommend!

shaila diaz
shaila diaz

Fast service, I ordered for pick up and it was ready as soon as I arrived. Pizza was great. I love the salad bar the veggies are always fresh.

Bubba Ray
Bubba Ray

First time visiting Rusty's in Santa Barbara. The pizza was yummy. It reminds me of Shakey's pizza and round table. The crust was crispy not soggy. We ordered the thin crust. Would repeat when we are in the area. Total was 23.93 for the large pepperoni pizza.

Lise-Mari Gillespie
Lise-Mari Gillespie

Rusty's Special : As it should be, it felt specially done to perfection. Enough toppings for each slice, thin crust that was crispy and not burnt. Went well with a chilled Grenache side note, would like to have some garlic to add. Quick service and will be back!

Location

Welcome to Rusty's Pizza Parlor, a charming and eclectic pizzeria nestled in the heart of Santa Barbara, California. Located at 232 W Carrillo St, this beloved establishment has garnered a reputation as a go-to spot for pizza lovers. With its unique medieval-themed décor and a warm, inviting atmosphere, Rusty's offers a dining experience that feels both nostalgic and delightful.

What sets Rusty's Pizza Parlor apart is not just its ambiance but the quality of its food. Customers rave about the pizza, with many claiming it's some of the best they’ve tasted in a long time. From classic cheese to innovative options like chicken barbecue, the flavors are consistently praised for their deliciousness and thoughtful preparation. The emphasis on a less greasy pizza allows the freshness of the ingredients to shine through, making each bite satisfying and indulgent.

The reviews speak volumes. Diners like Pasqual Gonzalez consider it their top choice, while Marlene Da Silva highlights the charming presentation of her chicken barbecue pizza as a visual and culinary delight. The salads, too, receive accolades for being fresh and well-prepared, rounding out a meal that is both hearty and wholesome.

Despite some feedback regarding service, with comments on a distracted staff or a less than welcoming environment, many patrons maintain that the pizza's quality and quick preparation make up for any minor hiccups. Guthrie Paterson calls it a “Santa Barbara institution,” emphasizing its role as a must-try for both pick-up and delivery orders.

In summary, Rusty's Pizza Parlor is a pizzeria that embodies the spirit of the community while serving up fantastic food. Whether you're dining in amidst the medieval motifs or grabbing a pie to go, you're in for a treat. Next time you're in Santa Barbara, make sure to pay a visit and discover the magic that this little parlor has to offer.